"Since we've put so much time and effort into it, it must be worthwhile"—even in tasks where this is the prevailing belief on the ground, there may actually be hidden processes that could be reviewed and improved.
💡 Key points of this article (3-line summary)
• Reducing steps does not equal cutting corners: By deliberately abandoning conventional wisdom, new value can be created.
• Example of a hugely successful sweet: The reason why cookies that eliminate the "rolling" step are going viral
The first step in DX is "disrupting the value chain": Before systematizing, first question the process.
*For companies that want to identify unnecessary processes in their own business workflow.
(▶ Click here for a free brainstorming consultation)
"Scoop cookies" and "upside-down cheesecakes" are attracting attention on social media and in the cafe market.
At first glance, these might appear to be fleeting trends or quirky product ideas. However, when analyzed from a business strategy perspective, they overturn industry norms and simultaneously achieve cost reduction and the creation of new appeal.A highly rational success story of "value chain disruption"It can be seen that this is the case.
This time, I'd like to consider the "value chain," which can also be applied to digital transformation (DX).
In today's highly competitive world, where differentiation from competitors is increasingly difficult, this small innovation in the confectionery industry contains important clues for rethinking one's own business structure.
Michael Porter's "Value Chain" and the traps we often fall into
The "value chain" concept, proposed by management scholar Michael Porter, breaks down a company's business activities into a series of processes: "procurement," "manufacturing," "shipping," "sales," and "after-sales service," and identifies how much value (attractiveness) is created at each stage.
According to traditional business theory,"To refine every single step of this process and execute it perfectly without cutting corners anywhere."This has been considered the standard approach. In particular, in the Japanese business world, there is a strong tendency to aim for "perfect quality" at every stage and to "add" new functions and services to exceed customer expectations.
However, if you try to do every step perfectly, costs will naturally increase, and the time it takes to deliver the product or service will also lengthen. The two sweets we'll be discussing today seem to be breaking new ground by directly defying this industry convention of "perfecting every step."
What was broken?: The abandonment of "common sense" in confectionery making.
(Please note that the following explanation of the confectionery process is a general overview based solely on the author's personal understanding. It may differ from the strict procedures used by professional pastry chefs and the confectionery industry.)
Traditional cookie making generally builds value through the following steps:
- Mix the ingredients.
- Let the dough rest in the refrigerator (a step to make it easier to handle).
- Shaping (the process of rolling out the dough evenly with a rolling pin and cutting it out with a cookie cutter to prevent uneven baking)
- Bake in the oven
In this process, the steps of "letting the dough rest" and "cutting out shapes uniformly" have been considered absolute prerequisites for maintaining the appearance and uniformity of the product's quality.
but,Scoop CookiesThis method completely eliminates the most time-consuming steps, "2. Letting it rest" and "3. Shaping." It boldly simplifies the process by simply spreading the dough haphazardly into the mold and putting it straight into the oven.
Also,Upside-down cheesecakeThe same applies here. The constraints (common sense) in manufacturing and transport, such as "spreading crushed cookie dough at the bottom and letting it harden" and "carefully removing it from the mold to prevent it from collapsing," have been eliminated by reversing the top and bottom of the structure.
Two major effects resulting from disrupting the process.
What makes these examples remarkable is that they don't simply result in "cost reduction through shortcuts," but simultaneously produce two important business outcomes.
Significant reduction in on-site labor and "production errors"
By eliminating the most time-consuming and nerve-wracking processes of "die-cutting" and "die-removal," the working time has been dramatically reduced. At the same time, skilled techniques are no longer required, and manufacturing and delivery failures (waste losses) such as "shape distortion or breakage" are brought close to zero. From the perspective of on-site productivity, it is an extremely rational system.
New experiential value and natural growth without relying on advertising costs.
Even more importantly, deliberately abandoning previous quality standards (uniformity of shape) has transformed into a "new experiential value" for customers. By not making the thickness uniform, a contrast in texture was created that is not found in conventional cookies: "crispy and fragrant on the outside, and moist and semi-raw in the center." In addition, the "live experience" of scooping up a large piece with a spoon and the "visual impact" of the upside-down presentation are powerful triggers that make customers want to share it with others on social media, functioning as a mechanism to attract new customers without spending a lot on advertising.
"Bold subtraction" in your business
When we review how we conduct our own business, do we unconsciously accept the processes created by past successes and industry customs as "assumptions that must not be changed"?
In an era where markets have matured and improvements based on past trends are no longer sufficient to make a difference, breaking the status quo requires not just "adding new budgets or functions," but also intentionally disrupting parts of existing processes and thinking in ways such as "reversing the order" or "shifting things slightly."
In digital transformation (DX), instead of thinking about which parts to systematize, the starting point for formulating the next growth strategy is to first review the processes, based on the business objectives and goals.
