[Prescription for Organizational Development, Part 1] "Another resignation letter has been submitted"—The real reason why employee turnover continues unabated

This is a fictional conversation between the president of a company and a professional engineer.

Professional engineer: "President, another employee is quitting."

President: "...Again?"

The president let out a deep sigh.

President: "Who's next?"

Professional engineer: "This is Mr. XX."

President: "That Mr. XX?"

Professional Engineer: "Yes"

President: "That's a problem... I was hoping he would continue to do his best."

Professional Engineer: "Did you ask about the reason for their resignation?"

President: "I heard about it."

Professional Engineer: "What?"

The president said, "'She wants to try something new.'"

Professional Engineer: "Do you think that's the real reason?"

The president was silent for a moment.

You can't know the real reason just by hearing the reason for leaving.

An employee is quitting.

The company will then inquire about the reason for resignation.

"I want to advance my career."

"It's due to family circumstances."

"I've found another job I want to do."

Of course, that might be the real reason.

However, the moment someone decides to leave the company may not be the day they submit their resignation letter.

Long before that,

"There's no point in staying here."

"No matter what you say, nothing will change."

"It's pointless to ask for advice."

It's possible that he was feeling that way.

Professional Engineer: "Mr. President, how has Mr. XX been doing lately?"

President: "When you put it that way..."

The president thought for a moment.

The president said, "He used to speak up a lot in meetings, but lately he doesn't talk much anymore."

Professional Engineer: "Have you come in for a consultation?"

President: "...Now that you mention it, they haven't been here recently."

Professional Engineer: "That's it."

President: "There?"

Professional engineer: "Instead of thinking about it after the resignation letter is submitted, look to see if there were any changes before that."

It's not that they "don't say it," but rather that they "stopped saying it."

When employees don't say anything,

"Our employees lack initiative."

"Young people these days don't express their opinions on their own."

I sometimes think that way.

But think about it for a moment.

When they first joined the company, employees used to ask a lot of questions, but before we knew it, they stopped asking any questions.

The employee who used to speak up in meetings has recently become silent.

Employees who used to come in saying, "I have something I'd like to discuss," have stopped coming.

this is,

Has that person changed?

Or,

Perhaps they learned that it's better not to say anything.

Does "Tell me if anything happens" really work?

President: "But I always tell my employees this."

The president said, "If anything happens, don't hesitate to tell me."

Professional Engineer: "That's important."

President: "Right?"

Professional Engineer: "So, when an employee reports a problem, what is the first thing the president says?"

President: "Huh?"

Professional Engineer: "For example,

"Mr. President, we've actually had a problem."

Let's say an employee reports this to us."

President: "Yes."

Professional Engineer: "At that time,

"Why didn't you say something sooner!"

"Isn't that what you're saying?"

president"……"

Professional Engineer: "Or,

"That's why I told you to do it properly from the start."

"Isn't that what you're saying?"

The president gave a wry smile.

President: "...I have said that before."

Professional engineer: "This happens in many companies."

President: "But it's only natural to give a warning when a problem occurs."

Professional Engineer: "Of course. But that doesn't mean we should just ignore the problem."

President: "Right?"

Professional Engineer: "However, that first comment can potentially change how employees react the next time a problem arises."

president"……"

A professional engineer said, "If you think, 'I'll just keep quiet for a while longer because I'll get yelled at again,' the problem will disappear from the president's sight."

Psychological safety does not mean "you can say anything and it's okay."

Now, here's a phrase I've been hearing a lot lately.

psychological safetyis.

President: "Does psychological safety mean we should be kind to our employees?"

Professional Engineer: "That's a common perception, but it's a little different."

Psychological safety is,

Being able to ask questions, express opinions, and report failures and problems without excessive fear of interpersonal risks.That's what it is.

Anything you say is acceptable.

You won't get scolded even if you make a mistake.

They will not be held accountable.

This isn't about creating that kind of workplace.

On the contrary, the opposite is more important for the company.

To identify problems quickly, create a situation where you can articulate them.

"Actually, I'm in trouble."

"I think this method is dangerous."

"I failed."

"A customer said this to me."

If these issues come to light early, the company can respond more quickly.

"Employees not saying anything" does not mean there is no problem.

President: "I see..."

The president crossed his arms.

President: "Considering that, we shouldn't assume that things are going well just because employees aren't raising any problems."

Professional engineer: "That's right."

President: "Perhaps we just can't see it."

Professional engineer: "That's a possibility."

President: "But what should we do?"

Professional Engineer: "First, take a moment to reflect on your own reaction when you listened to what your employees had to say."

President: "A reaction?"

Professional Engineer: "The moment you hear about a problem, do you immediately start trying to find the cause?"

President: "...I'll do it."

Professional Engineer: "Aren't you trying to give me the correct answer?"

President: "That's also a possibility."

Professional Engineer: "And then, aren't you immediately coming up with solutions?"

President: "...I do all of it (laughs)."

Professional engineer: "As the president, I want to solve the problem as quickly as possible (laughs)."

Try changing the first thing you say.

President: "So, what should we do?"

Professional Engineer: "Why not start with something simple?"

President: "What?"

Professional Engineer: "When an employee comes to me with a problem, the first thing I say is..."

Thank you for telling me.

I try saying that."

President: "Is that all?"

Professional engineer: "That alone won't change everything."

President: "Right?"

Professional Engineer: "But after that one sentence,

"So, what happened?"

"I asked."

President: "I see."

Professional engineer: "Before investigating the cause, I first ask for the facts."

President: "Indeed, I tend to ask 'Why?' right away."

Professional Engineer: "There are times when 'why?' is necessary. However, if you start by asking 'Why did you do that?' some people might hesitate to report anything in the future."

president"……"

Professional Engineer: "If you want to find a problem quickly, don't corner the person who brought the problem from the start."

It's not just major system changes that can transform a company.

When you hear the term "psychological safety,"

"We must conduct training."

"We must create a system."

"We must implement 1-on-1 meetings."

You might think that way.

Of course, there are times when systems and structures are necessary.

But before that, there's something I'd like to consider.

How does the company react when an employee says something?

When an opinion is expressed during a meeting.

When a failure is reported.

When improvement suggestions are made.

"Even if you say that, it's no use."

"I tried it before, but it didn't work."

"That's your job."

Are you repeating that kind of reaction?

vice versa,

"I see"

"So that's what you thought."

"Thank you for telling me."

Simply acknowledging that can sometimes lead to further conversation.

There may be things you can do before an employee quits.

After an employee leaves the company,

"I wonder why he quit."

That's what I think.

That's also necessary.

But actually, there might be something we can do before that.

Has anyone stopped speaking up in meetings recently?

Are there any people who have stopped coming for consultations compared to before?

Isn't there someone saying, "It's pointless to say anything anyway"?

And most importantly,

When an employee says, "There are no problems," does that really mean there are no problems at all?

I'd like you to think about this for a moment.

Instead of trying to find the cause after an employee has quit,

Listen to employees before they think, "I don't need to say anything more."

That alone might change how people perceive the company.

Professional Engineer: "Mr. President, the next time you talk to your employees, why don't you try changing the way you ask them questions just a little?"

President: "How should I ask?"

Professional Engineer: "Instead of asking, 'Is there a problem?'"

"Is there anything at work that's been bothering you lately?"

I try asking that question."

President: "...In that case, it might be a little easier to talk."

Professional Engineer: "And if you have anything to say..."

President: "Yes."

Professional Engineer: "First,

Thank you for telling me.

is"

The president smiled slightly and nodded.

President: "I'll give it a try."

next time

Employees can now speak freely and comfortably.

But will that alone change the company?

Do people truly perform at their best simply because they feel safe and secure in their work environment?

Next time, we'll think one step further.

"Mr. President, what do you think employees are working for?"

Copied title and URL